How Do I Know If My Car Starter Is Failing?

May 29, 2024

We rely on our cars to start reliably every time we turn the key, but what happens when the starter begins to fail? In this article, we'll explore the common signs of a failing car starter and discuss what you can do to address the issue before it leaves you stranded.

The Importance of The Car Starter

The car starter is a small yet critical component of your vehicle's ignition system. Its primary function is to engage the engine's flywheel and initiate the combustion process, allowing the engine to start and run. Without a functioning starter, your car won't be able to start, leaving you stranded and frustrated.

Signs of a Failing Car Starter

Intermittent Starting Issues
One of the most common signs of a failing starter is intermittent starting problems. You may notice that your car starts fine one day but struggles to turn over the next. This inconsistency is often a telltale sign that the starter is beginning to fail.

Clicking Noise When Starting
When you turn the key in the ignition, you may hear a rapid clicking noise coming from the engine bay. This sound is typically indicative of a faulty starter solenoid, which is responsible for engaging the starter motor. If you hear this noise constantly when trying to start your car, it's likely that the starter needs attention.

Slow Cranking
If you notice that your engine cranks slowly when starting, it could be a sign of a failing starter. The starter motor may be struggling to engage the flywheel properly, resulting in sluggish or labored engine cranking.

Smoke or Burning Smell
In some cases, a failing starter may emit smoke or a burning smell when attempting to start the engine. This can indicate that the starter motor is overheating due to excessive wear or electrical issues. 

What to Do If Your Car Starter Is Failing

If you suspect that your car starter is failing, address the issue promptly to avoid getting stranded. Here are some steps you can take:

Have Your Car Diagnosed
If you're experiencing any of the symptoms mentioned above, schedule a diagnostic check-up with Toole's Garage. We can thoroughly inspect your starter system, battery, and alternator to pinpoint the issue accurately.

Consider Replacement
If your starter is failing, replace it with a new or refurbished unit. Starter replacement is a relatively straightforward procedure for experienced technicians and can usually be completed in an hour.

Keep Up with Maintenance
To prolong the lifespan of your car starter and prevent future issues, be sure to follow your vehicle manufacturer's recommended maintenance schedule. This includes regular inspections and cleaning of the starter system components.


Experiencing car starter issues? Don't let it leave you stranded! Trust Toole's Garage to diagnose and repair your car starter with precision and expertise. Schedule your appointment today and get back on the road with confidence.

April 28, 2025
When it comes to wheel safety, lug nuts don’t always get the attention they deserve. These critical fasteners are what keep your wheels securely attached to your car, and they need to be tightened to a very specific level of force—known as torque. Get it wrong, and you're risking more than just a loose wheel.
April 15, 2025
Toole’s Garage is proud to announce opening of our Jackson, CA location - a family owned and operated full service auto repair shop that serves Jackson-Martell-Sutter Creek area.
April 13, 2025
It’s difficult to drive anywhere in the Bay Area and not see a lot of Subaru vehicles. Whether it’s the Subaru Crosstrek, WRX, Outback, Forester, or Ascend, Subaru vehicles are everywhere. At Toole’s Garage we are big Subaru fans. Subaru vehicles are built for the great outdoors, and of course California provides plenty of opportunity for on-road and off-road adventures. All wheel drive (AWD) comes standard on many Subaru models, and can provide consistent traction whether you are on a muddy road, or skiing in the Sierras. If a roof rack did not come standard with your model, it’s easy to add. And of course, interior space is pretty generous, especially if you drive an Outback or Ascent – you can stow plenty of camping and hiking gear. At Toole’s Garage we can provide your Subaru with the maintenance it needs to provide you with a reliable ride – wherever your adventures take you. We highly recommend regular oil change – it not only improves performance and extends engine life, but it also allows us to inspect various sub-systems of your Subaru to catch any impending problems (for example, older Subaru models were prone to oil leaks). And if a long summer trip is in the cards, we definitely suggest bringing it in for a checkup. Being a full service auto repair shop, Toole’s Garage can provide your Subaru with routine maintenance services, diagnostics, as well as major repairs. If your Subaru needs new brake pads, has the check engine light “on”, suffers from transmission problems, or needs major engine repairs – we can make your vehicle healthy again. Whether you have owned your Subaru for a long time, or have recently acquired one, bring it to our San Carlos auto repair shop – we will keep your vehicle in peak condition. Call us to make an appointment, or you can make an appointment online, on our website.
More Posts